Fishy Legal Tactics HOA Attorneys Have Used for Collections by Mitch Drimmer
Fishy Legal Tactics HOA Attorneys Have Used for Collections
Thinking outside the box can be great, especially in the homeowners association and condo association industry. It’s what makes our signature collections process here at Axela so successful.
But out-of-the-box thinking can be used against you, too. Attorneys are always looking for new ways to make the most money, even HOA attorneys. Time and again we’ve seen the tricks they use claiming to try to collect for your association, but really they’re just lining their own pockets. So often, using an HOA attorney ends with the association losing the money owed to them, and having to pay on top of that to cover lengthy legal efforts that didn’t succeed anyway.
Every time we hear stories about the crazy lengths some lawyers will go to when collecting for HOAs or condos, we start to think maybe the box is there for a reason.
Unjust Enrichment
A while back we talked about a community in a sticky collections situation. One of their unit owners had passed away, leaving a mortgage-free title to an heir. But, it came with a $13,000 tax certificate (which had been sold to an investor) and $17,000 owed to the association, as well as a tax-deed sale that had already been set. The perfect storm for the association to lose out on a hefty chunk of change. Now Axela was able to draft a clever plan to avoid that and had to act quickly to make it work, but if we hadn’t been called in, here’s what would have happened:
The HOA’s attorney wanted to let the unit go to the tax-deed sale and then file a suit for something called “unjust enrichment.” This is a claim basically stating that someone (in this instance, the investor who’d purchased the tax certificate) was paid at the expense of someone else (the association).
This is a risky play for a lot of reasons: first, if the tax sale goes through, the money owed to the association is ‘wiped out,’ meaning there is no chance of recovering money from the sale or from the owner after the fact. Additionally, if the judge found that the investor was not unjustly enriched (which is the likely outcome) their tax lien would have been rightly prioritized over association fees.
So the idea of unjust enrichment was a wild reach that was almost certainly going to be unsuccessful in recovering for the association. But it would have been a definite way to tack on a ton of hours in legal fees for the attorney, wouldn’t it?
Sneaking In New Rules
Fishy lawsuits aren’t the only questionable trick attorneys have up their sleeves. One client we worked with had an attorney attempt to completely ignore state statutes by advising the Board to modify the community’s governing documents to contradict state laws. This was complicated and unethical for several reasons, like the fact that governing documents don’t overrule state statutes (something an HOA attorney would be WELL aware of!) so the attorney’s time and counsel which they charged the association for were totally unnecessary.
To add insult to injury, these changes were made to try to force the bank to take responsibility for debt owed to the association, creating a lengthy legal battle as part of this ridiculous plan. Again, we’re seeing a trend of attorneys being paid but the association not recovering their lost income – in fact, the community often winds up owing the attorney more for their efforts and having to write off the bad debt from the delinquent assessments. Talk about throwing good money after bad!
Just Because it’s Legal Doesn’t Make it Ethical
Clearly, all HOA attorneys are not the same, and we hope that your community association’s attorney is an upstanding and ethical partner for your community. You need your attorney to be available to advise you on decisions the Board makes to help prevent future lawsuits and to deal with any that do come.
But your attorney is just one of the tools in your community association’s toolbox. Just as you wouldn’t use your HOA attorney (and pay their high fees) to perform management tasks, you also shouldn’t be hiring your attorney to perform collections. The attorney’s only recourse is to take the issue to the courts. That means pursuing foreclosure, or, if that’s not likely to be successful, trying some legal scheme like these that will get the attorney paid for their time, but is unlikely to end with money in the association’s pocket.
Treating People Like People
Thinking outside the box can be great, but the more we hear about the crazy legal hoops attorneys find to jump through that only seem to take advantage of the association, the more we think that they need the box.
There’s at least one ethical, merit-based way that has a 95% success rate when it comes to collecting debts owed to associations: Axela. Our proprietary technology and process empowers defaulted homeowners to set up payment plans they can actually pay off, rather than harassing them for lump sums of money they’ll never be able to repay, or putting them out of their home in a foreclosure.
Tags: Collections, Management News
These recent days, we are going through some real problems such as an increase in energy usage. Also, when it comes to solving these problems, people cannot really think of the solutions. Hence, we are here to provide the solutions on How to Reduce 
The collections process isn’t a fun one, and depending on what causes delinquency, it can get complicated. A homeowner who falls behind on just their association payments is one thing, but someone who’s so behind on all of their financials that they have to declare bankruptcy is a very different story. We’re asked all the time about what happens when a condo or HOA has to deal with homeowner bankruptcy. If your association is dealing with a bankrupt homeowner who is not paying their post-bankruptcy amounts, there are decisions to be made and steps that can be taken. Let’s review what must happen and how the community association can best navigate this situation.
What Happens When Bankruptcy is Filed?
Chapter 7 bankruptcy, also known as “no-asset” bankruptcy, is a complete wipeout. This means that no money will be recovered from the pre-petition amounts. A Chapter 7 bankruptcy case can take as little as six months to complete because there is no settlement to be made. Creditors can claim to the court that there are assets being hidden but, in most cases, it is all over fairly quickly. If the delinquent owner is not paying the post-petition amounts, then the association can wait until the case is discharged and then move forward with collections activity. If the owner has been paying their post-petition amounts, then the issue is resolved albeit the association has taken a hit.
Chapter 13 bankruptcy is known as a “wage earners plan” and is a workout where the court will make a settlement and oversee it until the payment plan has been completed. This is when the association needs to make a business decision.
They deliver services to residential, commercial, municipal, and utility clients in Michigan and Florida! With a desire to break stereotypes and bring the tree service industry into the 21st century, Corey designed a business with unparalleled service.
Corey Parshall
Most community associations have their budget meeting in the month of November for the upcoming year. By doing it in November there is plenty of time to print new coupon books and let the community members know what the new monthly assessments will be for the coming year.
After years in parking compliance and towing services, we saw a real need for organized, reliable, and effective security services for residential and commercial property managers.
FSW First Response Solution Inc. serves residential, commercial, government, and industrial clients. Through our top-notch, 24-hour security services, we’ll ensure your safety and protection.
All In One System – manage so many devices on you properties. you control access for owners and guests at your fingertips!
iDentyTech is a leading provider of intuitive Identity management products and solutions. Founded in 2010 IdentyTech™ provides its worldwide customers with best-in- class complete identity management solutions. We further offer custom engineered solutions for those customers requiring proprietary solutions. IdentyTech has field proven solutions for Corporate Enterprise, government and Financial services, healthcare, schools, Transportation, Small Medium businesses and many others.
Mulch for You