NEW PROVISION REGARDING FINING AND USE RIGHT SUSPENSIONS
NEW PROVISION REGARDING FINING AND USE RIGHT SUSPENSIONS
Prior to recent amendments to the procedures for fining and use right suspensions for non-monetary violations, there was a gap in the Florida Statutes regarding the manner in which a community association’s board of directors and its fining and suspensions committee coexisted, meaning there was no clear guidance with regard to whether the fining committee would first meet and then the board would levy the fine or if the board would first meet, determine the amount of the fine and then the fining committee would meet to provide the offending owner his opportunity to appear. That said, it was clear that if the fining committee did not agree with the fine, then the board could not authorize its levy against the offending owner. Well, now there is great clarity as to the procedural requirements.
Pursuant to the recent amendments to Chapters 718, 719 and 720 of the Florida Statutes, regarding condominiums, cooperatives and homeowners’ associations, respectively, the association’s board of directors must first levy the fine or use right suspension for non-monetary violations at a properly noticed board meeting. After the board of directors has levied the fine or use right suspension for non-monetary violations, the person who is to be fined or suspended must be provided with at least fourteen (14) days’ notice and an opportunity for a hearing before a fining and suspensions committee. The fining and suspensions committee must be comprised of other owners who are neither board members, nor persons residing in a board member’s household. The role of the fining and suspensions committee is limited to determining whether to confirm or reject the fine or use right suspension for non-monetary violations levied by the board of directors.
If the fining and suspensions committee does not approve the fine or use right suspension for non-monetary violations EXACTLY as levied by the board of directors, the fine or use right suspension for non-monetary violations cannot be imposed. If the fining and suspensions committee does approve the fine or use right suspension for non-monetary violations, which must be done by a majority vote, the association must then provide the person to be fined or suspended with written notice of the fine or use right suspension by mail or hand delivery.
Although the association may suspend the right to use the common areas, common elements, common facilities and association property, generally a use right suspension, whether for monetary or non-monetary violations, does not apply to that portion of common areas, common elements, common facilities and association property used to provide access or utility services to the owner’s property.
With specific regard to homeowners’ associations, prior to the recent amendments to the fining and use right suspensions for non-monetary violations provisions, a suspension of use rights could not impair the right of an owner or tenant to have vehicular and pedestrian ingress to and egress from their property, including, but not limited to, the right to park. However, as of July 1, 2015, this language has been revised to provide that a use right suspension may not prohibit an owner or tenant from having vehicular and pedestrian ingress to and egress from their property, including, but not limited to, the right to park.
The change from “impair” to “prohibit” in the Homeowners’ Association Act is significant in that the 2015 statute suggests that a homeowners’ association can impair vehicular and pedestrian ingress to and egress from the owner’s or tenant’s property so long as such impairment does not prohibit such access. For example purposes only, in gated communities, this new language lawfully allows a homeowners’ association to force the owner or tenant to use the guest lane, instead of the resident’s lane, at the community’s entrance gate.
For condominiums and cooperatives, a use right suspension does not apply to limited common elements intended to be used only by that unit, parking spaces, or elevators. Additionally, as of July 1, 2015 for condominium associations only, a use right suspension applies to a unit owner who owns multiple units even if the delinquency or violation that resulted in the use right suspension arose from less than all of the multiple units owned by that owner. This means that if an owner, who owns three units, has his use rights suspended due to a continued delinquency associated as to only one of the units, then, nevertheless, the suspension would apply to all of the units and not just the unit associated with the delinquency.
Tags: Budgets and Finance, Condo and HOA Accounting, Law and Legal
